Benign focal epilepsy with centrotemporal discharge (BECTS) or rolandic epilepsy is the focal epilepsy most often seen in childhood 1,2 and is not related to structural brain lesion 3 , although focal characteristics are well established. The main feature of this epileptic syndrome is the occurrence of seizures involving the orofacial region and, less frequently, the upper limb 4,5 . Seizures tend to occur during sleep or near sleep 6 , with preservation of consciousness and motor or sensory manifestations, accompanied by intense drooling and inability to articulate words 5,7 . The duration of each event is usually very brief4,8.9, but can occur in clusters 2 . The highest incidence occurs between six and nine years old and predominantly in males (2:1)9.10. Seizures and electrographic manifestations disappear in adolescence without sequela. The electroencephalogram (EEG) tracing is quite peculiar, with intense activation because of drowsiness or sleep and, when awake, the protrusion of the tongue can suppress epileptiform activity. The epileptic discharge predominates over the centrotemporal region, but may involve nearby areas, such as the frontal and parietal regions 2 . The main feature of this activity is the wave morphology, consisting of sharp wave or spike followed by a slow wave of high amplitude with the background activity completely normal. Recent studies shown that children with BECTS may have cognitive disorders (attention, memory short-term, visuo-motor, learning, oral dyspraxia, and language) 3,11−15 . The clinical symptoms of BECTS, as described by Lerman 16 , suggests that the source of the problem is in the lower rolandic cortex, representation of the face and throat, a fact corroborated by Holmes and Wong 17 . Failure in manual gestures test on command presented by children with BECTS can be explained by the interference of the epileptiform activity on brain areas responsible for programming and planning of movements or because the children had not yet acquired this skill (maturational development). The aim of this study was to evaluate the manual motor ability in children with BECTS and compare the result with the matched control group.
METHODS
Forty children with BECTS and 82 children without epilepsy (control group) were evaluated, and matched according to gender, age, and educational levels, through the application of Luria's fist-edge-palm test.
The children were requested to imitate as quickly as possible, sequenced movements with hands made by the examiner. This test was divided into two stages: a) with three identical movements (fist-fist-fist, edge-edge-edge, and palm-palm-palm), and b) with different movements (fist-palm-edge, fist-edge-palm, edge-palm-fist, edgefist-palm, and palm-fist-edge, palm-edge-fist). All test phases were explained by the examiner before each run. The perseveration of movements (perseveration an iterative repetition or continuation of an earlier response after the change request in the task) and inaccuracy in the execution sequence of movements after three attempts were consider failures. All children included in the study group underwent single photon emission computerized tomography (SPECT) in the intercritical period. Rotational type tomographic scintillation cameras were used for a wide field of view (Orbiter, Siemens, Hofman States, IL), which were coupled to dedicated image processors (Micro Delta, SIEMENS-Hofman States, IL), in the Nuclear Medicine Center, Department of Radiology, School of Medicine, Universidade de São Paulo (Laboratório de Investigação Médica – LIM-43). The topographic images were obtained 15 minutes after the intravenous administration of 1110 MBq (30 mCi) of ethylene-diylbis-L-cysteine diethyl ester dihydrochloride marked with technetium-99m (IPENCNEN, SP). Patients were positioned in line with the mental orbital perpendicular to the longitudinal tomographic litter. The images were processed using Butterworth filter in the frequency of 0.35 Nyquist order number 10. Cuts of 3 mm thick were obtained in the transverse, coronal, and sagittal planes. All children in both the study and control groups were evaluated for academic performance through the implementation of the School Performance Test (SPT). The SPT was applied by the examiner without the presence of family or any other spectator. The child investigated was required only to perform subtests in sequence, starting with the writing, followed by questions of arithmetic, and lastly with reading; the child also determined the closure of the test. To obtain the total score, the three scores of the subtests were added. This total has been classified by grade level and age of the child.
Parents or guardians of children who participated in this study signed an informed consent form approved by the Ethics Committee for Analysis of Research Projects of the Hospital das Clínicas of the School of Medicine, USP, Brazil.
RESULTS
Luria's fist-edge-palm task
The evidence of three sequential movements whether repeated or not, showed that only three (7.5%) children with BECTS were able to perform all the steps successfully, and one (2.5%) did not complete any sequence correctly. The higher frequency of failure was detected in tests with three different movements in sequence: only six children (15%) with BECTS performed the tests with no errors, whereas 24 (29.62%) in the control completed all phases of the test (Tab 1).
Number achievement | Study group n (%) | Control group n (%) |
---|---|---|
6 | 3 (7.5) | 25 (30.49) |
5 | 16 (40) | 26 (31.70) |
4 | 12 (30) | 15 (18.30) |
3 | 3 (7) | 11 (13.41) |
2 | 5 (12) | 5 (6.10) |
1 | 0 | 0 |
0 | 1 (2.5) | 0 |
Total | 40 | 82 |
All children in the study group were submitted to SPECT. Perfusion abnormalities, characterized by poor cerebral blood flow were observed in 12 children, except in one patient, who showed increased radiopharmaceutical concentration. The results were as follows: perfusion deficit in the right and left temporal region, the high concentration in the bilateral frontal region, perfusion defects in left temporal lobe, perfusion defects in the left temporal region, perfusion defects in the mesial right, slight irregularity in the left temporal lobe, perfusion defects in the left temporal and at the mesial and polar anterior temporal lobe, perfusion deficit in the bilateral temporal, left perfusion defects, perfusion defects in the right temporal region. Eleven children showed hypoperfusion in the temporal region and one showed increased radiopharmaceutical concentration in the frontal region.
School Performance Test
The evaluation of school performance of children with BECTS by SPT showed that three patients (7.5%) were classified as superior, 11 (27.5%) as middle and 26 (65%) as lower (Tab 2).
Classification | Study group n (%) | Control group n (%) |
---|---|---|
Superior | 3 (7.5) | 15 (36.6) |
Middle | 11 (27.5) | 12 (29.3) |
Lower | 26 (65) | 14 (34.1) |
The statistical analysis showed that there was statistically significant difference between the study and control groups for the hand movements searched through 3 identical movements (p=;0.007) and 3 different movements (p=;0.027). Children who obtained the lowest results in the hand gestures imitation also had lower school performance (p=;0.021). Another factor associated with the highest failures in actions by imitation movement was the abnormality in SPECT (p=;0.011).
There was no statistically significant difference between the results of the Luria's fist-edge-palm task or SPT and those found on SPECT.
DISCUSSION
The voluntary movement (praxis) is a complex functional system that incorporates a number of conditions or factors that depend on the synchronous operation of an entire group of cortical and subcortical areas 18 . The presence of oral dyspraxia in children with BECTS suggests a dysfunction of the lower rolandic motor area brain regions involved in the planning or execution of complex movements not linguistic 15 ; a few authors have also cited this region in their studies 12,19 . The evaluation of the sequential movement of the hands can be useful in the interpretation of the motor performance of children with BECTS and is useful for the evaluation of oral movement as both are linked to activation of the motor cortex. In 1992, Laub et al. 20 evaluated nine children with BECTS through neuropsychological and language tests and correlated the results of these tests with SPECT. The final conclusion of the authors is that there was no relationship between the findings and in the neuropsychological abnormalities in cerebral blood flow. Sarikaya et al. 21 analyzed the SPECT abnormalities in epileptic children and observed an inverse correlation between the asymmetry index of cerebral blood flow with the child's age at the time of onset of seizures, and a positive correlation with the frequency of crises. According Duncan 22 , the correlation between the laterality of the epileptic discharge and hypoperfusion was quite variable. The fist-edge-palm task (FEPT) was described by Luria, in 1966. The principle was applied to assess voluntary movement disorders, however, their approach exceeded this goal. Its application enables the investigation of frontal lobe functions and thus can serve as a screening to assess executive function, especially on the evaluation of movements with sequential components, imitation, and inhibition 23,24 . This test provides information about programming and planning of motor actions and the brain area involved in this production is the frontal region 25 . Currently, there are other brain areas, described as neural networks that are involved, including: bilateral sensorimotor area, supplementary motor area, left parietal cortex, and right cerebellum. There is no evidence of activation of the prefrontal area 23 . Ying et al. 26 concluded that the prefrontal cortex acts indirectly on the evidence of movement sequences, as a regulator. Recent studies have demonstrated the great importance of the premotor cortex in the recognition of motor action, especially in the planning required for the execution of complex motor sequences integrated into the parietal lobe 27,28 . The extensive involvement of frontal structures in motor activity does not stop there. Broca's area, which for many years been closely associated with the language (speech), plays an important role in motor activity, mainly on the observation and execution of hand movements. Neuroimaging studies demonstrate activity of Broca's area during imitation 29 . As highlighted by Nitrini et al. 30 , the reproduction and the sequenced movements require visual and verbal strategies (semantic) and this explains the difficulties that illiterate people have when carrying out this test when compared with people with higher education levels. In our study, children with low school performance had greater frequency of failure in performing sequential movements with hands. This fact strengthens the direct relationship between schooling and performance of the Luria's fist-edge-palm task. A few authors report that a generalized impairment in imitation of manual gestures was noted, which is often found in conjunction with speech apraxia and may reflect disturbance of Broca's area, which also subserves action recognition. In this study, no child had dyspraxia of speech 22,31,32 . Although hemispheric asymmetry with regard to production and execution of movement is important, the left hemisphere is more important to carry out purposeful movements and the right for exploratory activity. Crary 33 found no differences in the number of errors in sequencing of hands movement. All children in this study were right-handed and the tests were performed only with the right hand. Another approach of manual praxis and the sequencing of movements are to assess the kinetic and ideomotor ability of arms. The first was related to the fine motor skills for completion of tasks; the cortical location for this function is probably the motor cortex. The second, requiring more complex mechanisms including interpretative targeting involve cortical areas outside the rolandic region, such as the lower parietal lobe and supplementary motor area34 . Several studies describe neuropsychological abnormalities in children with BECTS, among then the attention and the executive process failure play a crucial role 35−38 . The poor results found among children with BECTS when compared to the control group can be explained by the presence of focal interictal discharge in the perisylvian region during the “active period” of epilepsy (presence of focal discharge) which would be responsible for damage to the frontal lobe connections affecting the development of attentional control, confirming previous studies 39,40 and this dysfunction would cause failure in school learning.